CCSC:South Central Paper Reviewing

Example Paper Review Form for CCSC South Central

6	Exceptional	Top 5%	Likely to be among the top few papers at the conference
5	Very Good	Next 15%	Very strong paper for the conference
4	Good	Next 15%	Suitable for inclusion into the conference
3	Average	Middle 25%	Potentially could be used as a conference paper
2	Below Average	Lower 30%	Correct but not very suitable for the conference
1	Deficient	Bottom 10%	Contains serious errors or deficiencies

Writing style, Organization, Clarity

Comments (Please be as constructive and specific as possible)

Content of paper, originality or builds on body of knowledge, potential usefulness to CS Educators

Comments (Please be as constructive and specific as possible)

Overall Rating of Paper and Appropriateness for CCSC

Recommendation to the program committee for acceptance of this paper(PROGRAM COMMITTEE ONLY)

6 Very Highly Recommend
5 Recommend the paper for the conference
4 Recommend with some reservations
about the paper
3 Neutral on any recommendation
2 Do not recommend, paper has difficiencies
1 Paper is not acceptable nor suitable
for the conference

Comments To PROGRAM COMMITTEE ONLY (not shown to authors)